Coakley's Restaurant & Irish Pub in New Cumberland but for some reason I don't get there often. On Saturday night my husband and I decided to head down for dinner. Although it was 6 p.m. on a Saturday, and we didn't have reservations, they were able to seat us in a booth right away. Coakley's has a very homey feeling with a distinct "Irish Pub" theme. My husband chose the Pittsburgh Pretzel Sandwich right away and it took me a little while to decide but I ended up getting the Chicken Pot Pie. I was very happy with my choice.
The pot pie was huge and the crust was delicious and flaky. I ended up taking over half of it home with me. The pretzel sandwich had ham and swiss cheese with coleslaw and french fries on top. The sandwich came with a side of their homemade chips which were very good as well. I definitely plan on going back to Coakley's sooner than later. I've heard they have good crab cakes. What does everyone else order there?